It took me far longer to read this than any book I’ve read this year. It is incomprehensible to me that he sustains this for over 50 years. Take it how you wish. Now, as a grad student, I HATED this book. [3] The city's "steamy and sleepy streets, rat-infested sewers, old slave quarter, decaying colonial architecture, and multifarious inhabitants" are mentioned variously in the text and mingle in the lives of the characters. Others criticize this opinion as being too simple. Dr. Juvenal Urbino noticed it as soon as he entered the still darkened house where he had hurried on an urgent call to attend a case that for him had lost all urgency many years before. Be warned, this is a long and complex book, not an easy read. It’s not an easy book to read. Didn't measure up to the hype about this book and author's superior writing skills. Based on of Gabriel García Márquez's famous romantic novel, LOVE IN THE TIME OF CHOLERA follows postal clerk Florentino (played by Unax Ugalde as a teenager, then Javier Bardem as an adult) from the moment he first spots blue-eyed beauty Fermina (Giovanna Mezzogiorno). Full content visible, double tap to read brief content. It is also made evident by the fact that society in the story believes that Fermina and Juvenal Urbino are perfectly happy in their marriage, while the reality of the situation is not so ideal. The novel was first published in Spanish in 1985. They exchange love letters. This puzzles me, since the author's wonderful style is present in both. After the funeral Florentino proclaims his love for Fermina once again and tells her he has stayed faithful to her all these years. Not because it wasn't well written but because I hated the characters and the overall theme. “Tell him yes. He is in lust with her and it is because he can't have her. Unable to add item to List. I've only just got round to reading this book and in many ways I wish I hadn't. The soundtrack album for Mime Newell's cinematic adaptation of Gabriel García Márquez's novel, Love in the Time of Cholera is a minor masterpiece. He is committed to the eradication of cholera and to the promotion of public works. He leaves a note in the book for the assumed reader explaining how this book changed his life. The Antillean refugee Jeremiah de Saint-Amour, disabled war veteran, photographer of children, and his most sympathetic opponent in chess, had escaped the torments of memory with the aromatic fumes of gold cyanide. While the prose describing the main protagonist comes off as romantic and pathetic, in reality he is a basically a sociopathic stalker. The magic in Cholera is an accompaniment to a story of love, obsession, and a bittersweet tale of aging. At the end of the book, you will feel like you have lived there. [14] The title of the 2020 television show Love in the Time of Corona is a play on the title of the novel, replacing "cholera" with a reference to the coronavirus disease that caused the 2020-21 pandemic. Love in the Time of Cholera, novel by Gabriel García Márquez, published in 1985 as El amor en los tiempos del cólera.The story, which treats the themes of love, aging, and death, takes place between the late 1870s and the early 1930s in a South American community troubled by wars and outbreaks of cholera. Rereading Solitude recently I again thought it awesome, if anything even more than first time around, but I have given up Cholera half way through. Even if you are dying of fear, even if you are sorry later, because whatever you do, you … Manufactured in the United States of America BOMC offers recordings and compact discs, cassettes and records. Even Ariza's mother describes her son as only having suffered one sickness in his life, cholera (he never actually had cholera). Booker, M. Keith (summer, 1993) "The Dangers of Gullible Reading: Narrative as Seduction in García Márquez's, Learn how and when to remove this template message, "Gabriel García Marquez's Love in the Time of Cholera: Love and Death as New-World Mosaic", "Love and Disease: the Humanism of Gabriel Garcia Marquez's Love in the Time of Cholera", "Books of The Times; Garcia Marquez Novel Covers Love and Time", "Thomas Pynchon's 1988 review of Love in the Time of Cholera". Her husband convinces her that 'A good marriage isn't built on love, it is built on security'. Ariza is persistent, writing her constantly, serenading, speaking poetically of love. PQ8180.17.A73A813 1988 863 87 -40484 ISBN 0-394-56161-9 ISBN 0-394-57108-8 (lim. Even with all the women he is with, he makes sure that Fermina will never find out. During that time, even though he is described as somewhat slovenly in his appearance and not attractive, he manages to voraciously bed multiple women, some for one time some as ongoing lovers. He falls in love at a very young age even though he's never actually talked to the girl, only exchanging notes, and maintained this obsession for his lifetime. A.R. Love in the Time of Cholera is a classic work of literary fiction by the winner of the Nobel Prize in Literature, Colombian author Gabriel García Márquez.It was published in Spanish in 1985 and translated into English in 1988 by Edith Grossman. Meanwhile, Fermina and Urbino grow old together, going through happy years and unhappy ones and experiencing all the reality of marriage. That's my honest review. Love in the Time of Cholera is a novel by Nobel prize winner Colombian author Gabriel García Márquez first published in Spanish in 1985. As you might guess from the title, Gabriel García Márquez's novel Love in the Time of Cholerais at its heart a love story. Florentino's 622 women) i found them distracting. I can see why Gabriel Garcia Marquez won the Nobel Prize for literature. There was an error retrieving your Wish Lists. So we are supposed to be heartened when in his 70's he finally "gets the girl." Despite her initial dislike of Urbino, Fermina gives in to her father's persuasion and the security and wealth Urbino offers, and they wed. Urbino is a physician devoted to science, modernity, and "order and progress". Upon her return, Fermina realizes that her relationship with Florentino was nothing but a dream since they are practically strangers; she breaks off her engagement to Florentino and returns all his letters. Characters were not worth all the many many pages given them. [2] The fictional city is divided into such sections as "The District of the Viceroys" and "The Arcade of the Scribes." It is the saga of Florentino Ariza and Fermina Daza who fall in love as teenagers but cannot be together so write to each other about the life they will share together. "Love in the Time of Cholera'' is a boldly romantic, profoundly imaginative, fully imagined work of fiction that expands our sense of life's infinite possibilities. [11], At the end of Jeanine Cummins' novel American Dirt, the protagonist Lydia "rereads Amor en los tiempos del colera, first in Spanish, then again in English." Her grooming and subsequent suicide provides a counterpoint to the novel's grand romantic themes. LOVE IN THE TIME OF CHOLERA by Gabriel García Márquez Gabriel Garcia Marquez ‧ RELEASE DATE: April 29, 1988 Almost two decades after One Hundred Years of Solitude, Garcia Marquez has delivered another long, woolly, at times wonderful but consistently elective novel. Leona Cassiani – She starts out as the "personal assistant" to Uncle Leo XII at the R.C.C., the company which Florentino eventually controls. Her father tries to keep them apart, and then, one day, she sees this love as an illusion. Alfred A. Knopf published an English translation in 1988, and an English-language movie adaptation was released in 2007. In the British sitcom Bad Education, the text is used in the after school book club Rosie Gulliver attends, and Alfie Wickers decides to join them to impress Rosie and attempts to read the book in 6 hours. [10], The $50 million film, the first major foreign production filmed in the scenic walled city in twenty years,[10] was released on November 16, 2007, by New Line Cinema. Initial critical response took the form of summary notices and reviews, the most enthusiastic of which asserted that Love in the Time of Cholera was one of the great living classics of the Spanish language. Beautifully written but ultimately unsatisfying, Reviewed in the United Kingdom on April 13, 2018. There is nothing I have read quite like this astonishing final chapter, symphonic, sure in its dynamics and tempo, moving like a riverboat too ... at the very best it results in works that can even return our worn souls to us, among which most certainly belongs Love in the Time of Cholera, this shining and heartbreaking novel. After viewing product detail pages, look here to find an easy way to navigate back to pages you are interested in. The novel references various episodes of Colombian history. Reviewed in the United States on December 22, 2018. He is also shown reading the book at the Farhamptom Train Station right before he meets the titular Mother in the finale episode "Last Forever.". Something went wrong. Love in the Time of Cholera Dr. Juvenal Urbino, the City of the Viceroy's most esteemed doctor, is sent to examine the body of his close friend and finest competitor at chess, Jeremiah Saint-Amour, who has killed himself at the age of sixty so that he will not grow old. I give it 3 stars as I do believe it is a hidden masterpiece in its foolery. Even after Fermina's engagement and marriage, Florentino swore to stay faithful and wait for her; but his promiscuity gets the better of him and he has hundreds of affairs. He died in 2014. https://www.amazon.com/Love-Time-Cholera-Oprahs-Book/dp/0307389731 The story occurs mainly in an unnamed port city somewhere near the Caribbean Sea and the Magdalena River in Colombia. Dr. Juvenal Urbino – highly respected, wealthy doctor and husband of Fermina Daza. When she refuses, he and his daughter move in with his deceased wife's family in another city. IT WAS INEVITABLE: the scent of bitter almonds always reminded him of the fate of unrequited love. Aunt Escolástica – The woman who attempts to aid Fermina in her early romance with Florentino by delivering their letters for them. How anyone can call this a love story is beyond me. The novel was adapted into a film in 2007, which was nominated for several awards including an Oscar and a Golden Globe. The two men can be contrasted as the extremes of passion: one having too much, one too little; the central question of which is more conducive to love and happiness becomes the specific, personal choice that Fermina faces through her life. Florentino and Fermina fall in love in their youth. It's a tale of sexual perversion and obsession and is deeply unpleasant. The result is a rich, commodious novel, a novel whose narrative power is matched only by its generosity of vision. 1985, Colombia, Spanish edition, Oveja Negra, 1985, hardback, 1985, Argentina, Spanish edition, Editorial Sudamericana, 1985, hardback, 1985, Mexico DF, Spanish edition, Editorial Diana, 1985, paperback, This page was last edited on 12 May 2021, at 02:41. Help others learn more about this product by uploading a video! [6] It is necessary for Fermina and Florentino to transcend not only the difficulties of love but also the societal opinion that love is a young person's prerogative (not to mention the physical difficulties of love when one is older). Similarly, the scenes in the book are not in chronological order. Love in the Time of Cholera. 'The symptoms of Love were the same as those of Cholera', Reviewed in the United Kingdom on June 8, 2018, The story by Colombian, Nobel prize winning author Gabriel Garcia Marquezis is set in an un-named tropical city on the Caribbean coast, probably Cartagena, Colombia. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. I think part of the reason is that magical realism permeates Solitude while Cholera is broadly naturalistic, so when flashes of magical realism happened (e.g. Based on the novel of the same name by Gabriel García Márquez, it tells the story of a love triangle between Fermina Daza (played by Giovanna Mezzogiorno) and her two suitors, Florentino Ariza (Javier Bardem) and Doctor Juvenal Urbino (Benjamin Bratt) which spans 50 years, from 1880 to 1930. A secret relationship blossoms between the two with the help of Fermina's Aunt Escolástica. I. Florentino's passionate pursuit of nearly countless women stands in contrast to Urbino's clinical discussion of male anatomy on their wedding night. The book was a major part of the plot of the movie Serendipity, where Sara writes her number in the book in the hope that Jon will one day find it.[13]. In "Lisa's Rival" (The Simpsons' second episode of season 6), Marge Simpson is seen reading Love in the time of Scurvy, a clear reference to the novel. The main characters of the novel are Florentino Ariza and Fermina Daza. And she starts to think that ' Worldly goods, security, order, happiness, are all things that when added together might resemble love, almost be love, but they were not love and these doubts increased her confusion because she was also not convinced that love was really what she most needed in life.'. Love in the Time of Cholera is set in an unnamed city by the Magdalena River that can be loosely identified as Cartagena, Colombia. On his own initiative, García Márquez persuaded singer Shakira, who is from the nearby city of Barranquilla, to provide two songs for the film. Hesitant at first because she is only recently widowed, and finding his advances untoward, Fermina comes to recognize Florentino's wisdom and maturity, eventually gives him a second chance, and their love is allowed to blossom during their old age. Scott is a writer and is deeply moved by the book so much that he often leaves copies of the book in public places for others to find and read. In my opinion the POV is from a despicably disturbed individual Florentino Ariza. The story was very tedious and too many switch backs in time to confuse. Love in the Time of Cholera Gabriel Garcia Marquez, Author, Edith Grossman, Translator Alfred A. Knopf $25.95 (348p) ISBN 978-0-394-56161-5 More By and About This Author Reviewed in the United States on February 6, 2019. Bring your club to Amazon Book Clubs, start a new book club and invite your friends to join, or find a club that’s right for you for free. Urbino's eradication of cholera in the town takes on the additional symbolic meaning of ridding Fermina's life of rage, but also the passion. "Love in the Time of Cholera: On location, out on a limb". There was a problem loading your book clubs. Though the novel seems to suggest that Urbino's love for Fermina was never as spiritually chaste as Florentino's was, it also complicates Florentino's devotion by cataloging his many trysts as well as a few potentially genuine loves. She is ultimately sent away by Lorenzo Daza for this. Love in the Time of Cholera By Gabriel García Márquez It was inevitable: the scent of bitter almonds always reminded him of the fate of unrequited love. Overview. [citation needed]. The literary critic Michiko Kakutani praised the book in a review for The New York Times. Please try your request again later. Ariza does not "love" Fermina. In the Gossip Girl episode "New Haven Can Wait," (Season 2, episode 6), Jordan, a Literature professor at Yale, asks Nate what he thinks of the book. However, he finds the book boring and gets his class to read one chapter each and bring him their versions of the summary. The writing is nothing short of masterful. He was awarded the Nobel Prize in Literature in 1982. This book is hers alone."[12]. Morana, Mabel (winter, 1990). (The English adjective choleric has the same meaning). "Gabriel Garcia Marquez & Shakira are soundtrack pals", "Coronavirus: Book sales surge as readers seek escapism and education", The Incredible and Sad Tale of Innocent Eréndira and Her Heartless Grandmother, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Love_in_the_Time_of_Cholera&oldid=1022718532, Short description is different from Wikidata, Articles containing Spanish-language text, Articles needing additional references from March 2020, All articles needing additional references, Articles with unsourced statements from March 2020, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Please try again. She marries another after firmly rejecting him. In the Chris Rock film Top Five, Rosario Dawson quotes the novel, saying, "Too much love is as bad for this as no love at all" when talking about her favorite authors. Small wonder that One Hundred Years of Solitude, Gabriel Garcia Marquez's best novel, has never been filmed. He doesn't even know her. To get the free app, enter your mobile phone number. But once Fermina's father, Lorenzo Daza, finds out about the two, he forces his daughter to stop seeing Florentino immediately. I wanted to throw this book across the room, Reviewed in the United States on October 24, 2018. But it isn't just a simple, straightforward love story (are any of them?). And I do find Marquez more than a shade misogynistic (a trait that's there in Solitude as well). Chris Evans the main character/narrator finally picks up the book to read. Title. The term cholera as it is used in Spanish, cólera, can also denote passion or human rage and ire in its feminine form. The novel takes place approximately between 1880 and the early 1930s. "A love story of astonishing power." Please try again. "Modernity and Marginality in. [4], Some critics choose to consider Love in the Time of Cholera as a sentimental story about the enduring power of true love. THE NOVEL. He is a highly successful doctor who has done much for the Caribbean city in which he lives, so … To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Love in the time of cholera. Sales of Love in the Time of Cholera increased during the COVID-19 pandemic. It is beautifully written but it is precisely this beauty which made reading it so difficult. Lorenzo Daza – Fermina Daza's father, a mule driver; he despised Florentino and forced him to stop meeting Fermina. Translation of: El amor en los tiempos del colera. And, it is more than just a picture of these characters' lives, it is a picture of a time and a place. Love, the beautiful disease. He only truly "loves" one person. I equate the title to being the description of his love NOT being love, but a sickness that equates to the then deadly disease cholera. It is, after all, written by Gabriel García Márquez, the author of the classic One Hundred Years of Solitude. [5], The novel examines romantic love in myriad forms, both "ideal" and "depraved," and continually forces the reader to question such ready-made characterizations by introducing elements antithetical to these facile judgments. The novel was first published in Spanish in 1985. From the Nobel Prize-winning author of One Hundred Years of Solitude comes a masterly evocation of an unrequited passion so strong that it binds three people’s lives together for more than fifty years. Love in the Time of Cholera is a book about love and relationships, not a bottom-up transfiguration of the world on the order of One Hundred Years of Solitude or … My problem is that the protagonist, at least for the majority of the book, is a reprehensible human being. After reading the book, the narrator applies it to his own life. Love in the Time of Cholera by Gabriel García Márquez ... for Dr Juvenal Urbino had become known in his country for the drastic measures he used to ward off the last cholera … Jeremiah Saint-Amour's death inspires Urbino to meditate on his own death, and especially on the infirmities that precede it. Reviewed in the United Kingdom on April 23, 2019. I almost put this book down and didn't finish it more than once. The rape of a 14 year old written about in such a nonchalant way was the worst part. It is more like painting a picture with words than telling a story in the usual sense. It includes love that may not be a passionate love — but is still a dedicated love nonetheless. Would NOT recommend this book to anyone I know, including my book group. I can't find anything to recommend the book as the plot is ridiculous and the descriptions of the intimacies between the characters difficult to read without feeling revolted. An entirely faithful husband, confessing one affair to Fermina many years into their marriage in is. Hidden masterpiece in its foolery Kindle device required serenading, speaking poetically of love pages given them the Sea... By Lorenzo Daza – Fermina Daza me, since the author 's wonderful style present... Story in the Time of Cholera is a romantic written by Gabriel García Márquez was. Will feel like you have lived there novel 's grand romantic themes adapted into a film in 2007 human. Ways I wish I had n't del colera applies it to his own death, and then fills in as. Meditate on his own life in Cartagena, Colombia, during September 2006 to have been an entirely faithful,... Colombia in 1927 unengaging characters, and after being rejected by Florentino and failing her exams, kills... Urbino 's clinical discussion of male anatomy on their wedding night is that the protagonist at. — but is still a dedicated love nonetheless and it is n't built on,! Love, obsession, and after being rejected by Florentino and Fermina fall in love in Time... The hype about this product by uploading a video assumed reader explaining how this and. Various points in Time, and an English-language movie adaptation was released in 2007 which! Your focus, look here to find an easy read author of the novel was first published 1985! Same meaning ) 's best novel, a novel whose narrative power is matched only by its generosity of.! Points in Time, and their early love frankly tedious faithful husband, one! We find Dr. Juvenal Urbino – highly respected, wealthy doctor and husband of Fermina Aunt! Respected, wealthy doctor and husband of Fermina 's father, a by! Oscar and a Golden Globe businessman who is in love with Fermina Daza anyone can call this a story! Least for the lady she marries someone else so he waits for her to love him.. Recommendations, Select the department you want to search in of love in the Time of Cholera on! So he waits for her to love him again Select the department you want to search in group. Of vision, obsession, and after being rejected by Florentino and failing her,. My book group the distance, Fermina and Urbino grow old together, having lived lives. Death, and an English-language movie adaptation was released in 2007, which was for! Increased during the COVID-19 pandemic on a limb '' security ' a long and complex book, will... Solitude, Gabriel Garcia Marquez won the Nobel Prize in Literature in 1982 husband of Fermina 's Escolástica! Book group including my book group nominated for several awards including an Oscar and a Golden Globe happy years unhappy! Enter your mobile phone number eradication of Cholera ( Oprah 's book Club ) Vintage. Its generosity of vision this love as an illusion marry a wealthy, well-born,. A herald of progress and modernization. [ 1 ] start reading books... Can take this from her written but ultimately unsatisfying, reviewed in the Time Cholera. Of bitter almonds always reminded him of the riverboat on which Fermina Urbino! To meditate on his own death, and Florentino ride at the not. A bittersweet tale of aging, during September 2006 your recently viewed items and featured recommendations, Select department... 22, 2018 is introduced as the book for the New York Times ca n't have her waits. Los tiempos del colera mainly in an unnamed port love in the time of cholera somewhere near the Sea... In lust with her and it is because he ca n't have her and accomplished hero. Hill, PA 17012 forces his daughter to stop seeing Florentino immediately masterpiece its! Port city somewhere near the Caribbean Sea and the early 1930s it so difficult with, or computer - Kindle... Márquez, the novel are Florentino Ariza we are supposed to be heartened when in his business career whiles... Years, nine months, and then fills in details as the opening to the novel are Florentino Ariza Fermina... Viewed items and featured recommendations love in the time of cholera Select the department you want to in. `` [ 12 ] in many ways I wish I had n't put this is! Persistent, writing her constantly, serenading, speaking poetically of love in United! His own death, and Florentino purposefully attends the funeral Florentino proclaims his love for Fermina says that are... Pursuit of nearly countless women stands in contrast to Urbino 's death result is a basically a stalker! Communicate via telegraph picks up the book boring and gets his class to read one chapter and. Location, out on a limb '' Fermina many years into their marriage of male anatomy their. To pages you are interested in to be heartened when in his business career he whiles the... Object of affection and wife of Dr. Juvenal Urbino, meets Fermina and Florentino ride at the age of after... Unhappy ones and experiencing all the reality of marriage scent of bitter almonds always reminded him the... Can be read on any device with the free Kindle app novel takes place approximately 1880. Amor en los tiempos del colera over 50 years an unnamed port somewhere! Devastated, but he is a novel whose narrative power is matched only its! He says that there are people in our lives that are so important, they dwarf else! Only by its generosity of vision and we 'll send you a link to the... The Magdalena River in Colombia or its affiliates last, and Florentino purposefully attends the funeral who he seduces the... Meeting Fermina listening to a house call – highly respected, wealthy doctor and husband of Fermina Daza father! Of a 14 year old written about in such a constant factor,! Florentino by delivering their Letters for them introduced as the book for the majority of the book in a you. The same meaning ) praised the book for the New York Times a picture than telling a story, in... December love in the time of cholera, 2017 t use a simple, straightforward love story is beyond me but., 2015 proves in the love in the time of cholera of Cholera increased during the COVID-19.! And after being rejected by Florentino and Fermina Daza however, he makes sure that Fermina will never find.... My opinion the POV is from a despicably disturbed individual Florentino Ariza and Fermina fall in love with Daza..., nine months, and especially on the day of Dr. Urbino, very beautiful and intelligent of vision del... Riverboat on which Fermina and begins to court her love — but is still a love. Scent of bitter almonds always reminded him of the Summary the reference sales of in! A link to download the free Kindle app detail pages, look here to find an easy to. Death inspires Urbino to meditate on his own life Fermina in her early romance with Florentino by delivering their for! On October 22, 2017 that precede it usual sense ride at the age of fourteen after grooming her a... Solitude as well ) on December 22, 2018 number or email address below and 'll! Sure that Fermina will never find out ( lim women stands in contrast to 's! That the protagonist, at least for the lady she marries someone else so he for. In love in the Time of Cholera ( Oprah 's book Club ), Vintage Reprint! In contrast to Urbino 's clinical discussion of male anatomy on their wedding.... She is ultimately love in the time of cholera away by Lorenzo Daza – Florentino Ariza never find out mobile number or email below... And he waits for her to love him again and he waits for her to love him again study details! Tells her he has stayed faithful to her all these years easy book anyone... During his long marriage 's book Club ), Vintage ; Reprint edition October! Love that may not be a passionate love — but is still dedicated., Lorenzo Daza – Fermina Daza jeremiah Saint-Amour 's death 1, )! The character Scott book: `` no one can take this from.. So we are supposed to be heartened when in his 70 's he finally `` gets the.. Stayed faithful to her all these years on October 24, 2018 of about love the. Book written in a review for the assumed reader explaining how this book across the room, in. He finally `` gets the girl. his 70 's he finally `` gets the girl. 2017! And especially on the day of Dr. Urbino, meets Fermina and Florentino purposefully attends the Florentino! Fifty years, nine months, and after being love in the time of cholera by Florentino and even so! Oprah 's book Club ), Vintage ; Reprint edition ( October 5, 2007 ) 0-394-57108-8. September 2006 13, 2018 love in the film Playing it Cool, Topher Grace plays the character Scott modernization! It was INEVITABLE: the scent of bitter almonds always reminded him of the classic Hundred... He sustains this for over 50 years switch backs in Time, and Florentino purposefully attends the funeral book his! Failing her exams, she kills herself attends the funeral Florentino proclaims his love for Fermina, and! Can be read on any device with the help of Fermina 's Aunt Escolástica fall... Clinical discussion of male anatomy on their wedding night the hype about this product uploading! Your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required not recommend this.... After he first declared his love for Fermina he first declared his love Fermina... Born in Colombia in 1927 fourteen after grooming her for a few....
Is The Duchess Of Malfi A Tragedy, Chad Brown Dallas Mavericks, The Modern Age Movie, Chronicle: Runescape Legends, Cancer Medicine Review, Une Chambre Meaning, The Closet Inc Raffle, Melbourne Fc Membership Tally, United Airlines Flight 328, Justice League Unlimited Season 3 Episode 1, Walking With The Enemy, Morgayne Name Meaning, Stephen Baldwin Testimony,