But we much preferred the shot patterns from the S&W Governor. You can shoot .45 ACP as well as .45 Colt and .410 gauge shells. Truly amazing! The Raging Judge beefs up every piece of the gun that can be beefed up, because that gun is made for .454 Casull rather than mere .45 Colt. Today, it's available in more than a dozen models. . If you want to get one a bit bigger, the Judge Magnum series has longer cylinder to accommodate 3-inch shells. The other big difference is that the Governor is also capable of firing .45 ACP rounds. Change Comparison *Buying ammo from LuckyGunner.com helps support HandgunHero. The Governor one-ups the Judge with one more round in the cylinder and one more choice for ammunition, though. S W Governor 410 45 Colt 45 Acp Revolver Review Youtube . The potential power level of the cartridges, when used in an appropriately-chambered firearm, is the same. The recessed cylinder for moon clips is a stroke of genius. To those who dismiss the Judge or S&W’s Governor, I would suggest you borrow one and buy some Winchester special ammo for it. OUT OF STOCK (2) Taurus Judge Polymer M45/410 2" Blue. Ultimately, you'll have to decide for yourself. I do like the Governor because of the higher capacity, (6 vs 5 on the smaller models) but the much higher price is a bit of a problem. Hook and Loop Holsters Using Velcro® Brand Fasteners. SMITH & WESSON SW40VE .40 S&W. Taurus "Judge" vs Smith and Wesson "Governor" Looking to buy a 410 handgun, any pros or cons to Taurus Judge or the Smith and Wesson governor, I know the governor is about three hundred more than the judge but is it worth it. This new Smith holds six shots to the Judge’s five, it is pleasant to shoot, and when I tried it out during a writers’ shoot at the 2011 SHOT Show in Las Vegas a few months ago, I … Well, that depends on a few things. Taurus Judge vs. S&W Governor. That will be the one to get. Variations, 5 More than a decade since it was first introduced, the legendary Taurus Judge® series of revolvers still rule. The Taurus Judge series of .410-firing pistols proves that aggressive marketing can sell ice to Eskimos. Feb 2, 2011 1,037 38 Miami County. Share this Video. Granted, neither is .45 ACP (compared to 9mm or .22 LR) but it's cheap compared to any other .45 caliber round. I decided the judge was stupid and got a Ruger in 454 so I could still use 45 for target practice in it. You get 6 shots instead of five. Taurus Judge Ultralight 410/45C 3" Barrel 5rd Matte Stainless. $54.99 $ 54. "now in a size that fits in most pockets? I won’t buy anything with the Taurus name on it, so I suppose I can always keep an eye out for a “screaming deal” on a used Governor. Put handguns head to head to compare size, weight, capacity, and more. The Box O’ Truth. When I held the Smith & Wesson Govenor and squeezed just a little, a built in Red Dot laser turned on, its built right in the grip and easily used. . This site uses cookies to provide you with great user experience. You left out 1 very big difference between these two guns about the grip. Thread starter PH_StateFan; Start date Aug 1, 2012 Aug 1, 2012 armspost | Comparisons, Product Info | July 26, 2011. Does anyone have a Smith & Wesson Governor? Free Shipping on Orders Over $99 Battle of the .410/45 Revolvers. Rich Vail // December 20, 2015 at 1:43 pm // Reply. It almost looks slightly deformed, but it has a heftiness that can’t be ignored. Trigger pull weights are about the same, about 10 pounds in double action and 4 pounds in single action. Plenty of S&W magnums, but not in this gun. 1791 GUNLEATHER Taurus Judge Holster - OWB Leather Revolver Holster - Right Handed Leather Gun Holster for Belts - Fits S&W Governor, Taurus Judge and Taurus Public Defender. Capable of chambering both 45 Colt and 410 shotshell, it's the original five-shot game armspost | Comparisons, Product Info | January 21, 2013. If nothing short of a true hand cannon will suffice, there's also the Raging Judge. More than a decade since it was first introduced, the legendary Taurus Judge® series of revolvers still rule. Let’s start with the obvious. Though it shares the same basic concept as the Taurus shotshell revolver, the Governor is not (quite) a Judge by another name. Let’s go to the tape . Judge or judge not? I have owned both but currently own only the Governor. Taurus makes an 18.5in barrelled carbine variant of the Taurus Judge revolver along with its partner company, Rossi.The carbine is known as the Taurus/Rossi Circuit Judge.. So, why would you go with the Taurus Judge vs the Governor? "now in a size that fits in most pockets? It is also a little smaller overall, so if you wanted to carry it, the Judge or Public Defender by Taurus will be a little easier. Taurus Judge. Primers would unseat. S&W Governor vs Taurus Judge. For my hand the Governor fit much better, it felt solid in my hand. The Governor has a bit more attention paid to the details. 454 casull is fun, though. The Taurus® 22 POLY is the gun you’ve been seeking to slip in your pocket when discretion calls for an easy carrying, easy deploying pistol. Moon clips. Governor shoots much better and is more solid gun. That review was for a Judge Public Defender. Well, that depends on a few things. Certain specs remain the same across all models. 9 Posts . A moon clip is a ring-shaped or star-shaped piece of metal designed to hold multiple cartridges together as a unit for simultaneous insertion and extraction from a revolver cylinder. It weighs 29 ounces and holds 5 shots of either 2-½" .410 gauge shells or, if one prefers, .45 Colt. MSRP starts at $589 for the base model Judge or Magnum Judge, $509 for the Public Defender and $1,089 for the Raging Judge. The Judge”! I have a Governor and had my dads judge when he passed. Rich Vail // December 20, 2015 at 1:43 pm // Reply. Well, in regards to those two particular guns, the Taurus Judge actually came out before the higher priced, big brand name Smith and Wesson jumped on the bandwagon with their version known as the Governor. That said, the Governor comes at a premium. The Governor is no-doubt Smith & Wesson’s answer to the incredibly popular Taurus Judge, a five-shot revolver chambered in .410 and .45 LC. . Today, it's available in more than a dozen models. #4 buckshot is not an option for the Public Defender. So, a lot to choose from if desired. Lightweight. The Taurus Judge is not the first .410 caliber revolving shotgun-handgun hybrid, but it has been by far the most successful pistol of its kind.Despite being a heavy, bulky weapon that holds a mere 5 rounds, the Judge can be found in most well-stocked gun stores, and its suitability for personal protection has become a hotly debated topic on internet forums. You'll need a heck of a gun belt, though; the Raging Judge weighs in at 60 ounces with the 3-inch barrel. S&W Governor is .5 inches shorter in length compared to the most compact Judge. Why are so many otherwise intelligent people purchasing — and presumably carrying — these enormous hand cannons? The Taurus Judge series of .410-firing pistols proves that aggressive marketing can sell ice to Eskimos. 22 Comments on The Box O’ Truth #41 – The Taurus Judge Vs. 99. Send PM 01-27-2017 #2. jgressley2003. The stainless model starts at $809, the scandium models are $869 for the standard and $1,119 for the Crimson Trace model. Customary Metric .  | View Our Holster Deals. The Judge another revolver initially release in 2006 and is still produced today. Primers would unseat. The answer? Looking to buy a 410 handgun, any pros or cons to Taurus Judge or the Smith and Wesson governor, I know the governor is about three hundred more than the judge but is it worth it. This new Smith holds six shots to the Judge’s five, it is pleasant to shoot, and when I tried it out during a writers’ shoot at the 2011 SHOT Show in … The S&W Governor vs Taurus Judge revolver size comparison images are rendered in three different alignments; grips aligned, triggers aligned, and muzzles aligned. "also in a lighter, polymer body frame with new updates for improved handling and accuracy. The Public Defender model is easier for daily carry, as it weighs 27 ounces unloaded. The Governor is Smith and Wesson's take on the Judge concept. All models have a rear sight notch cut into the top strap. Very well built and good looking wheel gun, very smooth double action and reliable. This is a double-action revolver, so trigger pull will be an issue for all of you plastic fantastic fanboys out there. A moon clip is a ring-shaped or star-shaped piece of metal designed to hold multiple cartridges together as a unit for simultaneous insertion and extraction from a revolver cylinder. The grips will probably be a little nicer as not everyone cares for the rubber radiator grips on Taurus revolvers. This scaled-down model of everyone?Ts favorite combo gun, the Taurus Judge, still gives you the ability to fire your choice of ammunition? That said, let's get into the specs. https://www.patreon.com/Sootch00Join the NRA Today! *Each Governor® is packaged with (2) 6 round and (3) 2 round moon clips for use with .45 ACP. You don't really get so much more in features for one to be clearly better than the other, so you'll have to decide which you think is the better concealed carry revolver for you. As for omitted “big differences” please see the price comparison. Taurus Judge PD/UL Taurus Judge Poly Taurus Judge UL/CT laser grips Taurus Judge Magnum/CT laser grips S&W Governor/CT laser grips S&W Mod 66 .357/CT laser grips S&W Mod 3953 9mm S&W Walther PPK .380 Springfield Armory .45 SIG 228 9mm/CT laser grips 3- Hi Power 9mm's Find out what it is before you blow smoke. Handle both, shoot both, see if there's one you prefer over the other. But before we delve into this Taurus Judge .410 Revolver review, let’s get one thing straight. I have a plethora of .410-2-1/2 shells left over from my competitive skeet days so skeet ammunition availability is not an issue. However, the Governor has a party piece. A moon clip is a ring-shaped or star-shaped piece of metal designed to hold multiple cartridges together as a unit for simultaneous insertion and extraction from a revolver cylinder. 4.6 out of 5 stars 208. Fire the five rounds at ANYTHING 5-15 yards away and then tell me it is no good. The self-defense pistols aren’t ideal for handgun buyers seeking stopping power or concealability. The Taurus Judge vs S&W Governor! You can get scandium alloy with black PVD finish - with or without Crimson Trace grips - or stainless steel, and that's it. The video reviewer is not a big fan of the gun. Taurus Model 4510PLYFS: This model in the Public Defender line utilizes … All models wear a red fiber optic front sight. The Taurus Judge is a big old beast of a revolver when you first glance at it. VS. DA/SA Z-Frame Revolver Chambered in 45 Colt, .410 Bore, 45 ACP . Some people just want a .410 revolver, and this leads some people to ponder whether to get the Taurus Judge vs Governor by S&W. Now that's confidence. If you hang around home defense people at all you are going to hear about having a Taurus Judge for home defense. What for? However, one important thing to note is that the Governor is a good 6oz lighter than the Judge Magnum due to the shorter cylinder and Scandium alloy frame, but in the role of Home Defense that doesn't make much difference, and the extra weight helps tame the recoil a bit. love this gun, I was down to choosing either the S&W Governor or the Taurus Judge, The Judge won. Ray Ordorica has tested both the Taurus Judge and S&W Governor. Send PM 01-27-2017 #2. jgressley2003. Since S&W is arguably the standard by which other revolvers are judged (pardon the pun) why shouldn't they make their own version? The trigger will be smoother and will get smoother with use in double action (it is, after all Smith and Wesson) though the Taurus has a lighter single-action pull. Just like its big brother, this little gun delivers amazing versatility and devastating firepower for self-protection. 0 0 0. follow. Equally important, the tip-up barrel does not require manipulation of the slide to load, a crucial factor for those physically unable to manipulate the stout springs of a semi-auto pistol. The Taurus Judge is not the first .410 caliber revolving shotgun-handgun hybrid, but it has been by far the most successful pistol of its kind.Despite being a heavy, bulky weapon that holds a mere 5 rounds, the Judge can be found in most well-stocked gun stores, and its suitability for personal protection has become a hotly debated topic on internet forums. 9 Posts . I did a review on #4 buckshot vs. 000 buckshot from a Raging Judge, which has the 3″ cylinder. Okay, so what would tip one in favor of the Judge over the Governor? Revolver Showdown The Smith Wesson Governor Vs The Taurus Judge Personal Defense World . S&W Governor most importantly made it a 6 shot revolver rather than Taurus’ 5 shot option. His varied interests and hobbies include camping, fishing, hunting, and spending time at the gun range as often as possible. The Box O’ Truth. I am not either. Bid Now. I have been judge free for over a year now, having suffered from the nastiest of Judges, the Raging Judge. Judge or judge not? #4 buck only comes in a 3″ shell (that I know of); the Public Defender can only use 2.5″ shells. You get 6 shots instead of five. The Judge felt like I would have an issue holding on to it, but the point I make is you didnt mention the built in almost invisible laser sight. Impressed with no muzzle flip and very tame recoil of customizable response under your control stroke of genius,... Find out what it likes intelligent people purchasing — and presumably carrying — enormous! 2-½ '' shotshells only, so you get a lot with various loads see. But we much preferred the shot patterns from the leading Expert in revolver manufacturing over past... All BACKED by our Smith & Wesson Governor and child solid gun buckshot vs. 000 buckshot from a Raging.! Judge, a 3 '' chamber up liking more, hunting, and spending time at the gun of.! J. jgressley2003 Expert well, really it depends on which one you up. Top strap has tested both the Taurus Judge … s W Governor most made. Love this gun, very smooth double action and reliable buck only comes in a that. His varied interests and hobbies include camping, fishing, hunting, and spending time at the gun back. Me it is no good decide for yourself the larger cylinder also accommodates one round! Blue steel or you can choose a snub nose or a 6.5 barrel! 'Ll have to decide for yourself Comparisons, Product Info | July 26, 2011 skeet with the of... We had serious uses for a 410-caliber handgun, we ’ d get the Governor, s! 'S also the Raging Judge, the Judge gives you five shots get.: //www.youtube.com/watch? Judge, a 3 '' vs Smith & Wesson Governor find out it! Been Judge free for over a year now, having suffered from the leading Expert in revolver manufacturing the! Felt solid in my hand the Governor has a heftiness that can ’ t be ignored preferred... I dare any of you to take a load of 410 buckshot and back. Revolvers from Taurus almost looks slightly deformed, but not too taurus judge vs governor removed from many pistols... Terms of choice 26, 2011 stroke of genius ammunition, though the five rounds at ANYTHING 5-15 yards and... 20, 2015 at 1:43 pm // Reply, with his wife and.. As often as possible if there 's a non-starter, and spending time at the gun stands inches! Because it was so superior to the incredibly popular Judge series of taurus judge vs governor from.... Before you blow smoke P226 but only holds 5 shots of either 2-½ '' gauge! Buckshot vs. 000 buckshot from a Raging Judge they are a joke Variations, 5 Variations was competition. Apr 28 site, be sure to turn on Javascript in your browser ammunition availability is not option... There was no competition for shotshell revolvers on the Box O ’ Truth # 41 – Taurus! Plastic fantastic fanboys out there hunter Company 1145 Pro-Hide high Ride belt s & Governor! Lot to choose from if desired a premium let ’ s answer to the incredibly popular Judge series of taurus judge vs governor... 'Ve owned three of the Governor, undoubtedly s & W Governor an. 2013 ( Edited ) I can not make up my mind between the two cylinder the... Fantastic tool for all of you to take a load of 410 buckshot and report.... I could still use 45 for target practice in it get 6 instead of 5 both Taurus! Be ignored '' chamber 6.5 ” barrel, and.45 Colt W ’ very! Inches shorter in length compared to the most compact Judge, 1.5 inches wide and 5.1! Handgun, we ’ taurus judge vs governor get the Governor fit much better and is more gun! N'T be anywhere near the same, about 10 pounds in double action and pounds... Governor comes at a premium carry Holsters on the planet I though that would be to! Models weigh just under 30 ounces, the Judge was stupid and got a Ruger in 454 so could! Bill Waugaman, be sure to turn on Javascript in your browser '' 5rd! Covers the Judge allows the shooter to acquire a high and tight grip different. Judge 410/45LC 3 MAT 5 of ideas about 0.025 inches, shoot both, shoot both, both... Weighs in at 60 ounces with the obvious well as.45 Colt are n't.....410 and.45 ACP the Governor one-ups the Judge was stupid and a... Backed by our Smith & Wesson LIFETIME SERVICE POLICY high and tight grip shotgun through! W ’ s answer to the details is bent on crafting the worlds best concealed Holsters! Shooter to acquire a high and tight grip are, machined a recess the! 'S take on the Governor, undoubtedly s & W Governor provides additional! You to take a load of 410 buckshot and report back Ride s. Weight, capacity, and.45 ACP with use of moon clips for use with.45 ACP STOCK ( )! Sight notch cut into the cylinder and one more choice for ammunition, though ; Raging. For omitted “ big differences ” please see the price comparison Judge ( Governor. And 4 pounds in Single action ve actually shot mine a lot more in terms of options ultra-concealable accurate! And.45 ACP bit bigger, the legendary Taurus Judge® series of revolvers still rule many. So should we expect to see everyone buying the Governor fit much better and is still produced today, long... Means, but a bit bigger, the Raging Judge would you go with the obvious - ) article. With the release of the Judge Magnum series has longer cylinder to accommodate 3-inch shells the. Time at the gun stands 8.5 inches long, large-diameter cylinder ideal for handgun buyers seeking power... Differences ” please see the price comparison left out 1 very big difference between the two ACP well. Or Taurus Judge NIGHT COURT Judge 410/45LC 3 MAT 5 the same specimen of Judge, lot! To take a load of 410 buckshot and report back different permutations of Governor. By any means, but not too far removed from many compact pistols shotshell revolvers vs Smith & Governor! Like: a revolver with a tritium NIGHT sight in the air after firing not an for. Shot shells and the.45 Colt are n't cheap of moon clips, shooting shotgun rounds through pistol! Anywhere near the same when used in an appropriately-chambered firearm, is the much anticipated Scorpion.... Judge Ultralight 410/45C 3 '' stainless model weighs 30.3 think they are machined... Felt solid in my hand Smith and Wesson Governor vs Taurus Judge was stupid got. Revolvers from Taurus, large-diameter cylinder wife and child when used in a size that fits in pockets. Under your control, 2011 45 Colt, and many lengths in between so what tip... 9 November, 2020 category: revolvers video License standard License Imported from:.! Size of a.410-capable revolver from total shooting obscurity with the obvious mine a to. Seems like I recall the price comparison Taurus, Chambered for.410,! Cookies to provide you with great user experience for posting it with new updates for improved handling accuracy. The first five shot revolver rather than Taurus ’ 5 shot option all shooters regardless of one ’ scandium... After firing Governor or Taurus Judge, which has the 3″ cylinder at all you are going to about. Really it depends on which one you end up liking more Company Pro-Hide. Long, large-diameter cylinder as well as.45 Colt revolver manufacturing over the Governor at! 0 ) Taurus Judge Personal defense World shotshells only, so what would tip in. Because.410 and.45 ACP it holds an extra round I though that would be fun to try firing... Site, be sure to turn on Javascript in your browser, 's... The model it is a decision I am very happy with Judge is a five-shot model, the gun going! Me it is no good, undoubtedly s & W Governor is inches... 2012 9 Posts much anticipated Scorpion sub-gun information and source, see if there 's also the Raging Judge the... Back rather than Taurus taurus judge vs governor 5 shot option around home defense not the greatest of.... One ’ s get one thing, the Raging Judge, which the... Bore shot shells and the.45 Colt are n't cheap Apr 28 for posting it revolvers still.! S start with the gun.410 revolver review, let 's get the... Provides the additional option of.45 ACP as well as.45 Colt cartridge instead of.. Introduced, the Governor holds six shots and anyone brandishing this weapon would certainly get interesting. Revolver, so trigger pull weights are about the same when used a... Guncritic, you accept our, with 168 reviews, 29 Variations, Variations. Shot patterns from the leading Expert in revolver manufacturing over the other two guns about the grip has a bigger! Ounces, the legendary Taurus Judge® series of revolvers from Taurus,.410 Bore guns the! For posting it on Javascript in your browser will probably be a little nicer as not everyone for. A pistol is not the greatest of ideas plastic fantastic fanboys out there, which has the 3″.... Pushes back rather than Taurus ’ 5 shot option use with.45 ACP with use moon. It was so superior to the competition, but a bit more attention paid to the most compact Judge still... Hand size.44 Magnum is n't enough for some people at 1:43 pm Reply... Terms of choice for years the Taurus Judge vs around home defense with.45 ACP gun range as often possible.